The Writ of Right and the start of Henry II’s legal reforms

 

Henry and Eleanor at courtAt the start of the reign of Henry II

As can be seen by the case of Battle Abbey, the legal system in the early years of Henry II’s reign left much to be desired.

If the defendant (as in the Battle case) was determined to prevaricate, the case would be dragged out interminably until it could be brought before the King.

With Henry this was difficult – he spent much of his time abroad and even when he was in England, he was furiously busy.

The problem of land ownership

Another difficulty at the start of Henry’s reign was the problem of land ownership. During the civil war in the past 19 years, there had been much transfer of land to supporters of Stephen. Henry was anxious to return things to the way they were at the time of his grandfather King Henry I, but there were difficulties.

Had Henry become King by conquest, things would have been easier – he could then have rewarded his supporters by taking land from Stephen’s supporters. However Henry’s succession had been decided by agreement – the Treaty of Westminster in 1153. So the option of just returning land to those who had held it in his grandfather’s reign was not always practicable. Some of his important supporters, such as the Earl of Leicester and Richard de Lucy had profited during Stephen’s time. Often he had to resolve matters by way of compromise.

With the proliferation of courts throughout the country under the control of different Lords, Henry had to exercise some control over land litigation. He did this by making it a rule that it was necessary to get a royal writ before starting a claim for land. AND that the only way that land disputes could be resolved was through the courts (ie not by self help).

The Writ of Right

The earliest writ was known as the Writ of Right. It was not new, but the requirement that it (or another of the Kings Writs) had to be obtained in land disputes was. This had several unforeseen consequences.

  • The number of Writs requested went up dramatically, leading the clerks in the royal chancery to devise a standard format
  • The King was forced to consider what he should do if the lord failed to comply with the writ, and
  • He also had to think about what he would do when people still used self help measures

The system that finally evolved is described in the Tractatus of Glanvill, the earliest law book we have, generally ascribed to Ranulf de Glanvill, Chief Justiciar of England between 1180 and 1189.

How it worked

A writ would be issued (after payment of the fee) from the Kings Chancery. This is an example of the type of wording:

Henry, by the Grace of God, King of the English …to the Abbott of Thorney, greeting. I order you to do full right without delay to Richard FitzAdam concerning one virgate of land in Twyell, which he claims to hold from you by the free service of five shillings a year, and of which Roger de Bachelor deprives him. And unless you do it, the sheriff of Northampton shall do it, that I hear no further complaint thereof for lack of justice. Witness Ranulf de Glanvill. At Geddington.

This writ, which is an example from towards the end of Henry’s reign, is a lot more specific than those issued earlier in Henry’s reign, which were often rather vague.

If the defendant defaulted and did not comply with the request in the writ, the plaintiff would then lodge a complaint before the Shire Court and produce his writ, authorising the Sheriff to act. The Sheriff would then appoint a servant and four or more Knights of the shire to go with him to the lords court, There he would declare that he had not received justice. The case would then be litigated.

As the Writ of Right was to decide the matter once and for all it was a solemn affair. It was important that both parties attend the hearings, but in medieval times this was not always possible (even if one side was not deliberately prevaricating) so there were endless adjournments.

The new assizes

Trial was normally trial by battle. This was not popular, as it was a chancy affair, and a party with more money could afford to hire a top champion. However one of the big innovations brought about by Henry was the development of the assize.

Here it is described by Maitland:

the action is removed out of the lord’s court and is brought before the king’s justices; four knights of the neighbourhood are summoned to choose twelve other knights who are sworn to say, to “recognise” (recognoscere), whether the demandant or the tenant has the greater right to the land. The name “grand assize” is transferred from the ordinance to the institution that it creates; these twelve recognitors are “a grand assize”.

So instead of being decided by battle (where God, it was hoped, would favour the righteous) the case was decided by 12 local Knights.

This was a massive innovation and very popular. However it was not as popular as the other, new forms of action developed by Henry. I will look at these next time.

Picture of Henry and Eleanor holding court is Wikipedia commons

Please feel free to add a comment. All comments are moderated but this is just to make sure no spam gets through.

There are no comments yet. Be the first and leave a response!

Leave a Reply

Wanting to leave an <em>phasis on your comment?

CommentLuv badge
This site is using OpenAvatar based on
Trackback URL http://www.historyoflaw.co.uk/writ-of-right-start-of-henry-iis-legal-reforms/trackback/
The Norman posts
What the Normans did for law in England

Looking back of over the Norman period and considering what impact they had on the English legal sys[more]

Westminster Hall

Westminster Hall has over the past 900 years held a central place in the life of the nation. It was [more]

Cadfael and law in the reign of Stephen

The Cadfael books cast a light on law in the reign of Stephen as well as the political history of th[more]

Oaths and Ordeals

Ordeals by fire and water and trial by battle - how they were used and descriptions of the events [more]

Sheriffs in Norman times

Introducing the office of Sheriff, an important one in English legal history. We will be looking at[more]

Writs, law and the nature of lawyer DNA

There is a big difference between law now and in Norman times which this post covers, along with som[more]

Custom and courts before and after the conquest

Looking at how England was divided for administration before the conquest and the three levels of co[more]

Henry I – The Lion of Justice

Taking a look at Henry I, what he was like and what his reign meant for the country. Henry I was a [more]

The Domesday Book

The Doomsday Book has been called Britain s greatest treasure. It is certainly unique and has been[more]

The Lord of the Manor

In this post, I am going to take a look at the lower end of the feudal system. The end that you and [more]

The Estates of Man in Norman England

Taking a quick look at the different levels of society and their names. If you want to know about K[more]

The Kings Demesne

‘Demesne’ is the word for land a lord keeps for himself. This post looks at the land kept by th[more]

Norman Barons: Writs and Relief

Here we look at the ‘head lessors’, the Barons. There was a massive change at this level of soc[more]

Landlord and tenure

This was the very first history post, and looks at the word ‘landlord’ and what it means, and al[more]

The Angevin posts
The Constitutions of Clarendon and the Becket affair

If anyone knows anything about the reign of Henry II, they know about the Beckett affair. About the [more]

Towns in medieval England

Medieval towns and cities or boroughs, would have a charter from the King, Lord or Bishop/Abbot gran[more]

Medieval slavery and unfree villeinage

Slavery was by no means absent from Medieval England. Whether villeins were the equivalent of slave[more]

The Kings courts and the start of the common law

Looking at how the rise of the Kings Courts lead to a reduction in the power of the lords to decide [more]

The petty assizes and the development of the jury system

The petty assizes were the new forms of action designed to maintain the status quo - the writ of nov[more]

The General Eyre and the Court at Westminster

In my last post I said I was going to be looking the new forms of action developed by Henry II, but [more]

The Writ of Right and the start of Henry II’s legal reforms

Henry II was responsible for many important legal innovations. For example land disputes now had to[more]

Battle Abbey v. Gilbert de Balliol

Here we have an example of actual 12th century litigation - the long drawn out case of the Abbey at [more]

A confusion of courts

I looked briefly at courts in my post here. However, now we have reached Henry II it is time to look[more]

The Cartae Baronum of 1166 and the Elephant

How the survey of 1186, known as the Cartae Baronum, allowed Henry to claim more under this feudal d[more]

The Exchequer in the time of Henry II

A discussion of the workings of the Exchequer in Henry IIs time, and the duties of the sheriffs, tog[more]

The Kings household and the administration of government

Looking at how the members of the Kings household, such as his Chaplin and chamberlains, were involv[more]

Feudal incidents

The incidents which went with the feudal system are the real reason why it lasted so long, This pos[more]

Crowned King of England

Looking at the coronation of Kings and considering if this is where they get their legal authority [more]

The Young King Henry II

Introducing King Henry II, a king who ruled for 35 years and who had a profound influence on the gov[more]